(315) 824-2300 • email us • reservations
1 Payne Street · Hamilton, New York 13346
Colgate Inn on FacebookColgate Inn on PinterestColgate Inn on TripadvisorColgate Inn on Yelp

Toll House Pie

$30.00 each Out of stock


The Colgate Inn's famous Tollhouse pie is a delicious and rich treat.  Just like a giant, warm and gooey chocolate chip cookie, it's irresistible on its own, and even better served with a scoop a vanilla ice cream. 

Dining Room Hours

Monday - Sunday 
7:00am - 10:00pm

To make dining reservations, please call (315) 824-2300.

Newsletter Signup

Sign up for exclusive offers and valuable discounts.